Random Recipe #4: Chartreuse soufflé

This month’s Random Recipe challenge is “Just desserts” – the recipe has to come from a book dedicated to desserts or baking, etc.  Or the sweet section of a normal cookery book.  I have several dedicated “sweet” cookery books, so I picked them out, and randomly picked one, which happened to be Le Larousse des desserts.  A lot of the recipes in it intimidate me because I just don’t think I’m a good enough cook to manage most of them successfully, so I was quite pleased with my random choice – whatever I ended up picking I would just have to try.  So out came the calculator and its random number generator, which directed me to… page  305.  Which happens to be in the soufflé section.  Great.  A bit like macarons, soufflés are notorious for being pernickety, and I would never normally attempt one (nobody ever wants to attempt a dinner party dessert with a higher failure than success rate).  But a challenge is a challenge, and I wasn’t about to back down.  Plus, the fact that I had to try it provided a good excuse in case it went wrong…

The wonderful thing about Kat and Craig is that I know that if I attempted a soufflé for them and it turned out a complete failure (highly likely), they wouldn’t judge me on it, we could drink more wine and everything would be fine.  Definitely reassuring, and clearly they were going to be the only witnesses to the attempt.  There were two options on page 305: chocolate soufflé and Chartreuse soufflé.  I actually burst out laughing when I saw the second option – Craig has been saying for most of the academic year that we have to make Kat try Chartreuse.  The choice was therefore an obvious one, and I attempted it last night, helped by Kat and Craig (thanks guys!).

I could have actually used the title “How to stack all the odds against you when attempting a soufflé” for this post for the following reasons:
1.  I’ve never made soufflé and I feel first attempts of any kind of recipe are always more liable to go wrong.
2.  The recipe requires a soufflé dish of 16-18cm.  There are no soufflé dishes of that size anywhere in St Andrews.  I didn’t have enough time to order one online.  So I had to use individual ramekins, which meant adjusting the cooking times, but no indication was given in the recipe, so we were going to have to sit and just watch the soufflés and guess when they were ready.
3.  One of the ingredients (fécule) can be translated five different ways.  I chose to go with cornflour, because that’s what I had in my cupboard, but when I spoke to my mum the evening before the attempt, she reckoned it meant potato flour.  Not a confidence booster.
4.  My oven doesn’t heat evenly.  Not even close.
5.  By the time we got round to actually making the soufflé, we were all exhausted and had already consumed Pimm’s, G&Ts, wine, more wine and shots of Chartreuse.  A recipe for making mistakes, right there.
6.  Speaking of making mistakes, I accidentally used icing sugar instead of caster sugar.

Somehow, against all expectations, the soufflés worked!  I’m not sure how this happened, and I think it might be a fluke, but still, wow.  Granted, they weren’t all that presentable, but they tasted good, and considering I was expecting a total failure, that’s definitely enough for me!  So will I be trying soufflés again?  I’m not sure.  They’re not that practical to make for dinner parties, since they have to be timed to the minute and served immediately.  Perhaps savoury soufflés would be easier to deal with in that sense.

Chartreuse soufflé

Serves 4-6
Recipe from Le Larousse des desserts

I’m giving the original recipe for a single soufflé dish, but I will also include the timings if you’re using little individual ramekins (I used 4 ramekins, but they were very close to being over-filled, so I’d suggest using 5 or 6 ramekins).  The recipe notes also suggest making this with Grand Marnier, and I’m sure most strong liqueurs would work.


3 eggs
25cl whole milk
20g caster sugar
6cl Chartreuse
2 sponge fingers
30g butter
15g cornflour (or potato flour)
40g all-purpose flour
1 small packet vanilla sugar (about 7g)
Extra butter and caster sugar for the dish/ramekins


1. Pre-heat the oven to 200°C.  Butter the soufflé dish (or ramekins) and sprinkle the inside and edges with caster sugar.  Separate the egg yolks from the whites, reserving both.

2.  Heat the milk and caster sugar in a saucepan.

3.  Using a pastry brush, imbibe the sponge fingers with Chartreuse.  Crush the sponge fingers and set the remaining Chartreuse aside.

4.  Melt the butter in a large saucepan.  As soon as it starts to bubble slightly, remove from the heat, add the cornflour and flour, and mix well before adding the vanilla sugar.  Return to the heat.

5.  Add the boiling milk to the butter and flour mix, and bring to the boil whilst stirring constantly.  Remove from the heat, and add the egg yolks, mixing well.  Pour in the remaining Chartreuse, and mix until smooth.

6.  Whisk the egg whites to stiff peaks, and once the Chartreuse mix has cooled enough, add the egg whites and gently fold them in, taking care not to break them.

7.  Pour half the mixture into the soufflé dish (or split between the ramekins), sprinkle the crushed sponge fingers on top (or divide between the ramekins), and pour the rest of the mixture over the top (or, once again, split between the ramekins).

8.  Bake in the oven at 200°C for 5 minutes, then turn the temperature down to 180°C for a further 25 minutes (or for a further 15 minutes if using small ramekins – you can tell they’re when the tops of the soufflés are golden brown), making sure not to open the oven door at any point.  Serve immediately.




Filed under Recipes, Sweet Foods

11 responses to “Random Recipe #4: Chartreuse soufflé

  1. belleaukitchen

    I love the way this is thoroughly thought out, making sure that you picked guests who wouldn’t judge you should it go wrong but still went ahead and stuck to the challenge regardless… which I thank you for wholeheartedly. I must say, they look fabulous so your worry was for nothing… lovely stuff!

    • Mel

      Thanks Dom! I think my competitive streak kicked in (though competitive against what, I’m not sure) when I realised how low my chances of success were, and I just HAD to see if the soufflé would work – I guess that’s the great thing about the challenge, it can make you try completely new things! I’m already excited for next month’s challenge…

  2. Looks really good!

  3. A brave response to a challenge – actually I think drinking shots of Chartreuse is pretty brave in itself. I think they look perfectly presentable – I’d definitely eat one (or two).

  4. Lou

    It seems that your random recipe turned out to be the perfect one. Well done- great job. I’m not sure I have ever had Chartreuse.

    • Mel

      Thanks! Chartreuse is quite particular – quite aniseed-y and quite strong. I’m not a massive fan of aniseed, so I don’t think I’d be able to do more than two shots straight, but I don’t mind the flavour in things (like soufflés…), if that makes sense.

  5. Hats off to you! It’s great to have friends who are game partners in a mad adventure … and look at the outcome! Those are beautiful little puffy souffles!

  6. Good for you brave one! I’m still scared to try and make these, but I’m thinking I’ll give it a go!

    Lots of yummy love,
    Alex aka Ma What’s For Dinner

    • Mel

      I’ll be honest – I’m still not quite sure how they turned out ok! Judging by the odds I managed to stack up against myself, it’s clearly quite a foolproof recipe! Do let me know how you get on if you do try soufflés..

  7. Pingback: Sharky Oven Gloves turns one! | Sharky Oven Gloves

Share your thoughts…

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s